Only accepted work is recordedAboutGuidesContactSign in
CitePepCitePep
Replication requests/Replication call
Replication callPosted by Example Journal · 14 Aug 2026 · closes 31 Mar 2027 · Illustrative

Replication requests

Replication requests ask other labs to repeat a key result, with public credit for those who do. The record below is an illustrative example of one.

Does symbiont shuffling explain recovery after the 2024 heatwave?

The claim to test: colonies that shifted to clade D recovered 40% more marine cover within 12 months (the original authors, 2026). Any lab may register a plan; every attempt is recorded on the original paper.

The claim is narrowed to one testable statement on purpose. A call to replicate a whole paper is rarely taken up, because the cost is unbounded and the result is ambiguous; a call to test one figure, with the threshold for a match agreed in advance, is a job a lab can scope. The original authors are told when a plan is registered, and the attempt appears on their paper whichever way it comes out.

Funders use the same mechanism in reverse. A call attached to a finding they have already paid to produce is a cheap way to find out whether it holds, and the registered plans tell them who is willing to test it before any money moves.

The claim
Colonies that shifted to clade D symbionts recovered 40% more live marine cover within 12 months than colonies that did not.
the original authors (2026) · bioRxiv 10.1101/2026.08.14.507812 · Results, Fig. 3
What counts as a replicationAgreed with the original authors before any lab started
DesignField or lab heat stress, clade assessed before and after
Minimum sample≥ 40 colonies per group
OutcomeLive cover at 12 months, same scoring method
Consistent ifEffect ≥ 20% in the same direction, 95% CI excludes 0
Labs taking part3 of 4 lab places taken
A marine research centreField · 2 sites · plan registered 2 SepRunning
A third independent labRe-analysis of shared data · effect 34% (CI 12–55%)Done · consistent
A second independent labLab heat-stress assay · starts NovRegistered
At a glance
Results in1 of 3
So farConsistent
Original authorsData and code shared
Credit
Each lab is credited on the original paper’s record and on its members’ profiles, whatever the result.

Related replication requests and records

Ask another lab to repeat a key resultData and code get their own trust recordExpert review of your preprint, for your eyes onlyEvidence summaries that stay current