Panel statements record dissent rather than hiding it. The record below is an illustrative example of a panel that did not reach agreement.
A split panel is a result, not a failure. Where experts in the same field read the same evidence differently, averaging them into a single sentence hides the thing a decision-maker most needs to know. The statement records each position, who holds it, and what evidence would settle the disagreement, so the reader can see how far apart the experts actually are rather than inferring a consensus that does not exist.
Each position names its own evidence. A reader who disagrees with the majority can follow the minority's citations directly, which is the practical difference between a recorded dissent and a footnote saying the panel was divided.
The panel split. Four experts say beaches can reopen after two samples below 8 µg/L taken 24 hours apart. Three say a passing sample isn’t enough while scum is still visible, because toxin levels near the shore can jump within hours.