
The Essentials of Async Work Culture
This is the CitePep accuracy record for “The Essentials of Async Work Culture”, published by When Notes Fly. It lists every change experts checked and accepted on that page.
Asynchronous work: collaborating without everyone available at once. The conditions it needs, such as documentation, and where it breaks down.
What has been corrected on this page?
Every accepted correction to this page is recorded with the exact change, so readers can see how the page improved over time.
-
A claim-level statistics check of this article: 2 study claims with no locatable published source were removed.
BeforeA 2021 study in the Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication analyzing 10,000+ Slack messages across 50 remote teams found that messages requiring follow-up clarification averaged 127 words with 1.2 structural elements (headings, lists, etc.), while messages that stood alone averaged 89 words with 3.1 structural elements. | Conciseness with structure outperformed length without structure.
AfterRemoved. | Removed.
Why: Each study and survey figure in the article was checked against the published source. Claims for which no published source could be located were removed.
View the full record → -
A review of the measurement-evidence and async-writing sections of this article found that most specific statistics, while attached to real researchers and companies, could not be verified against their actual published research, and one claim conflated two separate real Amazon practices as if they were one.
The sections were rewritten to keep the real people, companies, and general findings while correcting or removing the specifics that did not hold up.
What the page claimedThe article attributed a '15 minutes on diversion activities' figure to Microsoft researchers Shamsi Iqbal and Mary Czerwinski, without noting that a related and better documented '23 minutes to refocus' figure actually comes from Gloria Mark's research; described Shopify's 2023 meeting purge as having 'crept back within six months' without a documented source for that detail; cited a 2021 Journal of Knowledge Management study of 200 software teams with specific percentage figures that could not be verified; cited an Intercom 'five completeness criteria' training program with a 40 percent improvement figure that could not be verified; and described Amazon's bar raiser hiring process as evaluating candidates on six-page narrative memo quality, conflating the internal six-page memo practice with a separate, shorter candidate writing exercise.
What was correctedThe section now correctly attributes the well-documented '23 minutes to refocus after an interruption' finding to Gloria Mark, who has collaborated with Iqbal and Czerwinski on related Microsoft Research work, describes Shopify's real 2023 meeting purge (led by COO Kaz Nejatian, publicly championed by CEO Tobi Lutke) using its actual reported early results rather than an unverified six-month rebound claim, describes documentation's value in accurate general terms rather than citing an unverifiable specific study, removes the unverifiable Intercom framework and statistic, and describes Amazon's internal six-page memo practice and its separate bar-raiser hiring writing exercise as the two distinct practices they actually are.
Why: Web searches for each specific statistic and case detail either found the real figure belonged to a different researcher, found no evidence the specific study or program exists, or found that two genuinely real practices at the same company had been described as one.
Since the underlying researchers, companies, and general findings are real, the sections were rewritten to correct or remove the specific inaccuracies rather than deleting the material outright.
View the full record →
Who checked this page?
1 contributor has checked "The Essentials of Async Work Culture" on When Notes Fly. Each name below links to that person's public CitePep profile, where every contribution they have made is listed with the exact change they proposed.