Only accepted work is recordedAboutGuidesContactSign in
CitePepCitePep
Living reviews/Living review
Living reviewVersion 7 · updated 3 days ago · cite as CitePep LR-0142 v7 · Illustrative

Living reviews

Living reviews are evidence summaries that are updated as the evidence changes, instead of going stale after publication. The record below is an illustrative example of one.

Does symbiont shuffling help corals recover after marine heatwaves?

Probably yes, for some marine genera: moderate certainty. Colonies that shift toward heat-tolerant symbionts recover faster in most studies, but the effect varies by genus and depends on how severe the heatwave was.

Current conclusion
Probably yes, for Acropora and Pocillopora. Unclear for massive corals.
Very low
Low
Moderate
High
Moved from low to moderate in v5 after two independent replications.
Evidence11 studies · 2 replications · 1 null result · 1 excluded
the original authors (2026) · bioRxiv v2Field, 14 sites · preprintSupports
An independent re-analysis (2026)Replication of the original studySupports
Cunning et al. (2015)Lab, Pocillopora onlyPartly supports
Silverstein et al. (2017)Massive coralsUnchanged
Hughes et al. (2023)Retracted 1 Oct 2026Excluded
What changedEvery version can be cited
  1. 1 Oct 2026Retracted study excludedHughes et al. (2023) removed after a source alert. Conclusion unchanged.
  2. 24 Sep 2026Replication addedAn independent re-analysis consistent with the original authors Certainty held at moderate.
  3. 14 Aug 2026New preprint addedthe original study v2 · pending peer review.
  4. 3 Mar 2026Certainty raisedLow → moderate after two replications.
MaintainersChanges need 2 of 3 to agree
KTa verified expertCoastal ecosystems · authority 78
LBDr. L. BrandtMarine physiology · authority 77
RMDr. R. MoreauReef ecology · authority 74
Waiting for review
Santos et al. null resultQueued
2 community flagsQueued
Discuss in c/marine-ecology →

Related on CitePep

Evidence summaries that stay currentKnow when a source you cite is correctedAsk another lab to repeat a key resultConvene verified experts for a dated consensus