Only accepted work is recordedAboutGuidesContactSign in
CitePepCitePep
Guides/Contributing/How to check a page for accuracy
Contributing4 min read · Beginner · Updated Sep 2026

How to check a page for accuracy

Checking another page for accuracy is a clear, specific craft, and the record you leave makes “reviewed for accuracy” mean something.

Checking someone else's page uses the same method as checking your own, with one difference: the verdict goes on both records, theirs and yours.

What that produces, at volume, is a map of where errors actually live. Of 1,249 categorised corrections accepted on CitePep between 1 July and 6 October 2026, 738 were a plainly wrong fact, 529 a source that did not carry the sentence citing it, 123 a stale figure, 110 a missing-context problem and 58 wording that outran its evidence. Fabricated quotes, invented thresholds and reversed findings came to 3 each.

The method: claim by claim

Work through claims individually rather than forming an impression. Isolate each checkable statement, the facts, figures, dates, quotes and causal claims, and verify each against a source. Same rigour as reviewing your own article, with one advantage: the claims its author stopped seeing are the ones you notice first.

  1. Check claims one by one

    Verify each against a primary source where one exists. 529 of the 1,249 corrections were a citation that resolved to something saying less than the sentence did, so the link opening is not the check.

  2. Mark each claim’s status

    Verified, corrected, or still to confirm. This is the part that survives: a reader six months later can see which claims were examined.

  3. Flag what’s still open

    “To confirm” is information, not a gap in your work. It tells the publisher precisely which sentence needs a source.

  4. Propose sourced fixes

    Give the corrected wording and the source. A proposed fix is what can be accepted; a flagged problem has to be re-researched by someone else.

The per-claim verdict is the whole value

“Looks accurate” gives a reader nothing to act on. “A, B and C verified against sources; D corrected with a citation; E flagged for confirmation” is a record, and it is the form the 1,753 accepted corrections here take: each carries its category, its reason, and the text before and after.

918 of the categorised ones were a single clean error. The other 331 arrived tangled, usually a wrong fact sitting in the same sentence as a source too weak to hold it, which is exactly why per-claim beats per-page.

Handle the open claims honestly

Some claims will not resolve: no primary source exists, or reputable sources differ. Mark those rather than waving them through. “No primary source found” tells the publisher which sentence needs one.

Where sources genuinely conflict, say so. One correction here narrowed an article's JWST framing for overstating the implications and left the surrounding astronomy alone, because the rest was already right. Scoping the claim is usually more accurate than replacing it.

i

An accepted review on CitePep lands on the page and on your profile, where it feeds a per-topic score: 203 of those exist across 7 contributors and 200 topics. Checking pages in one subject is what builds standing in it, see why attribution builds trust.

A per-claim verdict is what turns “reviewed for accuracy” into a record readers can rely on.

Turn the check into accepted, credited work

Propose the corrected wording with its source, rather than reporting the problem. That is the difference between a correction that can be accepted and one that goes back into someone else's queue: of 1,758 contributions recorded here, 1,753 were accepted and 1 rejected, and the accepted ones arrived with the fix attached.

Each accepted item lands twice, on the page history and on the contributor's per-topic score.

Common questions

How does checking for accuracy relate to reviewing a page?

A review judges the whole page: accuracy, clarity, structure. An accuracy check asks only whether each claim is true. See how to review a page for the broader judgement.

How many claims should I check?

Every claim you can verify, load-bearing statistics first. Then state what the check covered, because a scoped check is usable and “all good” is not.

What do I do with a claim I can’t verify either way?

Mark it “to confirm” with the reason: no primary source found, or sources disagree. That names the sentence needing work.

Should I check claims outside my expertise?

Check what you can trace to a primary source and name the rest as outside your scope. A marked boundary makes everything inside it credible.

What’s the difference between checking my own work and someone else’s?

Same method. The advantage is fresh eyes: you see the sentences its author stopped reading. The other difference is that the accepted review is credited, so it feeds your score in that topic.

Was this guide useful?